INTERVIEW: Vella Lovell Is Embracing the Mess

Text: Luna Bacce.
Photos: JJ Geiger

Five seasons into Fox’s hit comedy Animal Control and fresh off Peacock’s record-breaking drama The Five-Star Weekend, Vella Lovell, the Juilliard-trained actor, opens up about tarantulas, comedic chaos, and learning how to pour back into her own cup.

Sometimes the set demands a nuanced emotional breakthrough; on other occasions it requires letting a live tarantula crawl across your face. For Vella Lovell, filming Season 5 of Animal Control demanded the latter. “I had to leave my body momentarily to get through it, but I’m very proud of myself,” she laughs. That willingness to surrender control, both in front of the camera and in her own life, captures exactly where the actor stands right now.

Best known for scene-stealing turns in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Mr. Mayor, and The Big Sick, Vella is currently thriving in two vastly different worlds. Sharing the screen with Joel McHale on the Fox and Hulu sitcom, her by-the-book character, Emily Price, sees her careful composure unravel as an HR review puts her reinstatement on the line and her romance with Shred finally comes into the open. Meanwhile, Vella also plays opposite Jennifer Garner in Peacock’s Five-Star Weekend, which shattered records as the platform’s most-watched scripted series and secured a Season 2 renewal. Vella is an artist in constant evolution without ever needing everything neatly arranged.

Vella sat down with us, and we talked about what happens when Emily stops enforcing order, the guest star who nearly halted production from sheer laughter, and what her own ideal five-star weekend looks like today.

We’re five seasons into Animal Control. When you first met Emily Price, did you ever imagine her life—and especially her love life—would become this complicated?   

I never could have imagined Emily would be experiencing these trials, but it’s what I hoped for. When I first read her on the page, I hoped for a journey of her coming into herself and finding her feet, and I think that’s exactly what she gets to do this season. 

Emily’s job is under a microscope this season, with the HR review threatening her reinstatement. What did you enjoy about getting to see Emily fight for something that means so much to her?

I think this season we really get to see her thrown off her axis. The theme of this season is that every single character is turned on their head, and she’s no exception. Emily, at her core, is a rule follower and is used to enforcing order—now she’s losing her cool, playing pranks, scared of commitment—she’s just much messier. This season we really get to explore how much Emily loves the precinct and wants her job back, but also that she’s not willing to sacrifice her new relationship with Shred and her own integrity. She’s growing. It’s a really exciting new layer and character development for her that is very satisfying to play. I really love Emily—she’s so earnest and awkward, and I’m proud of her.

Emily and Shred aren’t hiding anymore. What changes once you get to play them as an actual couple rather than two people dancing around their feelings?

This season has been so fun, getting to really be in this relationship and diving into that with Michael. I think we learned this season that Shred and Emily are total weirdos. They’re such little weirdos! I’m glad they found each other. They’re both very positive and sweet puppies, but Emily is neurotic and passive-aggressive, and Shred can bury stuff down and then explode later. They actually have a lot of conflict as they dive into dating, but they always come back together and gain a deeper understanding of each other. We get to see Emily and Shred in all of these new firsts, and really enjoy each other, which is really satisfying to experience after so many seasons of dancing around it.

Joel McHale has such a specific comedic rhythm as Frank. At this point, can you tell when he’s about to improvise and throw something unexpected at you?

No. Joel keeps me on my toes. Both as an actor and a person—I can never tell when he’s joking or being serious, and I am the most gullible person alive, so we’re a fun combination.

Who in the cast is most likely to make you break character?

Honestly, everyone has cracked me up at some point in time. Grace can get me pretty consistently. In a group scene, if you check in with Kyla, she will absolutely be doing the weirdest things in the background, and it kills me. Gerry Dee will surprise you with these random lines out of nowhere that can mess me up. And in terms of guest stars, Oliver Hudson did an episode with us last season, and he was so funny and bizarre that I actually couldn’t get through the scene without laughing. I had to not look at him, because I was really holding up production.

This show has humans trying to act rationally while animals create total chaos. What has been the funniest—or most unpredictable—animal you’ve had to work with?

I had to work with a spider this season. A tarantula crawled up my face. I had to leave my body momentarily to get through it, but I’m very proud of myself!

Give us three words that describe where Emily’s journey goes in Season 5.

Mess! Relationship! Growth! 

In Five Star Weekend, you share scenes with Jennifer Garner, who also executive produces the series. What was it like developing that chemistry with Jennifer?

I only had one day on set with Jennifer, but it was an absolute dream, and I learned so much from her. She’s very kind, generous, and attentive. It was inspiring to watch someone at the top of their game be that relatable and warm. It was very easy to step into the shoes of her manager, Chelsea, who believes in her and thinks she’s amazing because, well, same!

The show asks some interesting questions about female friendship and how relationships change as our lives evolve. What did working on the series make you think about friendship in your own life?

I loved the series so much. I think Bekah Brunstetter did an incredible job adapting it for television and expanding the themes and characters of the book. I think it’s a fascinating concept—to watch five different women come together and wonder what they have in common, and then to realize they’re diverse facets of Hollis’ own life and unique phases and women she’s been. I think often we’re expected to stay the same person throughout our life, when in reality we are constantly changing, growing, or even calcifying. Of course, our friendships are going to reflect that. Watching the show made me appreciate and celebrate those different women I have both been and befriended throughout my life.

Jennifer Garner’s Hollis is famous for creating the perfect experience for everyone else—so what does a five-star weekend look like for Vella Lovell?

So, I am working on boundaries. I need to get better at advocating for myself to get time to really decompress and be alone. I love spending time with my baby and husband, catching up with friends and being out in the world, and yet sometimes I can forget to ask for time to pour into my own cup. I think that’s a common experience of women and mothers, and it’s good to remember that we deserve to take up space and ask for time alone or with our friends. If your cup is full, you can actually give so much more to those around you. 

CONNECT WITH VELLA LOVELL:
INSTAGRAM